MozillaZine

Mike Pinkerton Proposes Changes to Camino Code Review Process

Friday October 3rd, 2003

Camino project lead Mike Pinkerton has outlined some proposals for kickstarting the development of the Mozilla-based Mac OS X browser, which has stalled in recent months. At the moment, Mike personally reviews every single Camino patch, a strategy that is no longer practical now that he cannot work on the browser full time. This has made him somewhat of a bottleneck in the development process and caused frustration for would-be contributors.

In future, Mike proposes, each patch should receive two peer reviews from members of the community before being super-reviewed by Mike himself. Any developer will be able to provide one of the peer reviews, as long as he or she knows Cocoa, the native Mac OS X application environment. These changes should free Mike up from having to personally check every line of every patch and encourage more people to contribute to the project.

The two reviews rule will be relaxed as contributors become more familiar with the Camino code and some developers may eventually gain direct checkin access to the Camino directory of the source code repository. However, Mike will reserve the right to veto any patches that he feels are not suitable for the project, in line with the Camino ethos.


#1 Bravo!

by Catfish_Man

Friday October 3rd, 2003 9:46 PM

Reply to this message

Looking forward to Camino getting back on track!

#2 Um

by Kovu <Kovu401@netscape.net>

Saturday October 4th, 2003 7:44 AM

Reply to this message

I thought Camino was supposed to bite it in favor of Firebird?

#3 Re: Um

by MozSaidAloha

Saturday October 4th, 2003 8:19 AM

Reply to this message

I hope that Camino does not die....Since Moz F-Bird is getting started on OSX, it seems very weird to use now. Also, I find Camino *faster* on my 900 MhZ G3 iBook than Moz F-Bird or the App Suite. I just hope this works out...

#4 Re: Um

by willll <willll@juno.com>

Saturday October 4th, 2003 8:57 AM

Reply to this message

not according to the roadmap

#6 Re: Um

by mlefevre

Sunday October 5th, 2003 10:41 AM

Reply to this message

Not sure what made you think that. On the contrary, there was discussion that Firebird wouldn't bother with a Mac OS X version because Camino was already there, but people wanted a XUL-based thing on the Mac, so Firebird is made for Mac too (although there's not been as much work done on Mac Firebird)

#5 Gah

by Catfish_Man

Saturday October 4th, 2003 10:19 AM

Reply to this message

I can't believe how many people picked up that rumor that Camino was going to die. They specifically posted a ton of stuff saying it wasn't (on the roadmap, for example)

#7 They're losing ground

by anthropolemc

Sunday October 5th, 2003 6:38 PM

Reply to this message

Good to see some changes happening Camino-wise. They've gotta get back on track; I know a lot of people who have ditched Camino in favor of Safari mainly because it's being more actively developed.

#8 makes sense

by pbreit

Monday October 6th, 2003 2:29 PM

Reply to this message

People probably suspected that Camino was going away because that makes the most sense. Mozilla is in dire need of momentum and critical mass. Pursuing both Firebird and Camino prevents this. While native widgets are generally better, the momentum is behind Firebird (soon to be Mozilla).