Responses to Mozilla Column in 'The Guardian'

Friday July 18th, 2003

As many readers will remember, last Thursday's edition of The Guardian newspaper featured a column by Jack Schofield that criticised several of Netscape's and Mozilla's development decisions, prompting a strong reaction from many MozillaZine readers. Yesterday's Guardian featured two letters responding to the piece. The first points out the advantages of Mozilla's cross platform nature (which Schofield criticised) and the second highlights the work of mozdev, which is only possible due to Mozilla's open source nature. Both letters praise Mozilla for being vastly superior to Internet Explorer. Readers of the print edition of The Guardian can find the letters on page 23 of the Life/Online supplement.

#3 Mozdev would be possible without open source

by Yacoubean

Friday July 18th, 2003 1:13 PM

You are replying to this message

You said, "...the work of mozdev, which is only possible due to Mozilla's open source nature." If Mozilla were complety closed source, mozdev could still exist as a place for Mozilla addons. No, most of the addons at mozdev probably wouldn't exist with out open source Mozilla, but that's beside the point. There are tons of addons for IE, and someone could (and probably has) make an IE addon/development site similar to Mozdev. My mozdev project, DailyComics, uses the mozilla activex control (DailyComics is written in Delphi), and I have never touched the mozilla source code.