MozillaZine

Full Article Attached Mitchell Baker on mozilla.org and Phoenix

Saturday October 5th, 2002

Mitchell Baker, mozilla.org's Chief Lizard Wrangler, has posted a newsgroup message about mozilla.org and the Phoenix project. The post explains why mozilla.org is supporting Phoenix and how the development will affect the main SeaMonkey project.


#1 Fine, but...

by prometeo

Sunday October 6th, 2002 1:53 AM

You are replying to this message

I do agree with the posting, but a few things are not clear at all: 1) Will Phoenix be "ported back" to Mozilla (ie, integrated)? 2) Will Minotaur (Mail/News equivalent to Phoenix) be integrated in Mozilla sometime in the future? 3) What about Composer (with all its links to Mail/News codebase)? 4) What will happen to all the existing extensions (Enigmail, Cascades, etc.)?

Seems to me there is a lot of duplicated effort: developers fix bugs in the UI for the trunk, while other engineers are developing a complete substitute. Don't get me wrong, I really like Phoenix and I have a few old machines which will benefit greatly from a standalone browser, but I fear that having more and more branches in the main Mozilla codebase will end up in a very-difficult-to-manage situation. Look at NS7: in many tests it outperforms Mozilla (even latest builds) and the relative fixes didn't find their way to the trunk. No flame involved, just some cinic thoughts.